Chapter 11

How Do You Handle Conflict?

From Hope for Troubled Marriages by Dr. Ken Newberger

There are five conflict styles in marriage. Each one weighs getting the outcome you want against protecting the relationship. Learning to work together more often (Our Way) helps both spouses get what matters to them.

Five Ways to Deal with Conflict

The five conflict styles in marriage A chart with Outcome on the vertical axis, from unassertive to assertive, and Relationship on the horizontal axis, from uncooperative to cooperative. My Way (competing) is high on outcome and low on relationship. Our Way (collaborating) is high on both. Half-Way (compromising) sits in the middle. No Way (avoiding) is low on both. Your Way (accommodating) is low on outcome and high on relationship. Outcome ASSERTIVE UNASSERTIVE My Way COMPETING Our Way COLLABORATING Half-Way COMPROMISING No Way AVOIDING Your Way ACCOMMODATING UNCOOPERATIVE COOPERATIVE Relationship

The chart above reflects the five major ways people approach conflict and negotiation, both inside and outside of marriage.1

Notice, the five patterns reflect two larger axes of conflict: importance of outcome vs. importance of relationship. That is, which is more important, doing things the way you want them done or the well-being of the relationship?

More Detail

My Way

I insist on doing things the way I want them done.

Outcome is of #1 importance.
Relationship is #2.

No Way

I avoid dealing with what either of us wants.

Outcome is of 0 importance.
Relationship is also 0.

Your Way

I yield and accommodate to what you want.

Relationship is of #1 importance.
Outcome is #2.

Half-Way

I try to compromise and find solutions mid-way between us.

Outcome and Relationship are important enough that we each get part of what is important to us.

Our Way

I seek to work collaboratively so we both get what we want.

Outcome and Relationship are both of high importance. We strive for a “win-win.”

Discuss

Which Conflict Styles Do You Use?

Practice

Exercises in Collaboration

Survival Exercise

Cartoon of a small deserted island with palm trees, for a couples collaboration exercise.

You learn that you and your spouse are going to be left on a deserted island for an undetermined period of time. You can choose only four items from the following list. Each of you selects two, but you must agree on all four together.

  1. AM/FM shortwave world band receiver installed with new batteries
  2. Walkie-talkie set with new batteries for on-island communications
  3. Flint fire starter
  4. New cigarette lighter
  5. Propane stove with 1 lb. propane bottle
  6. One pot
  7. One frying pan
  8. Five days’ worth of canned food
  9. Animal trap
  10. Two gallons of bottled water
  11. Two (empty) canteens
  12. Large single blade knife
  13. Hatchet
  14. Swiss Army knife
  15. Tent
  16. Two blankets
  17. Two sleeping bags
  18. Large net
  19. One change of clothing for each person
  20. Map of region
  21. Compass
  22. Two backpacks
  23. Rubberized raft with oars
  24. Two life preservers
  25. Two bottles of sunblock lotion
  26. Flare gun with six flares
  27. Loaded 8-shot revolver
  28. Bow with 5 arrows
  29. Twenty-five feet of rope
  30. Two rolls of duct tape
  31. Shovel
  32. Ten rolls of toilet paper
  33. A dozen novels
  34. First aid kit
  35. Bible
  36. Two dozen condoms
  37. Rx bottle of antibiotics
  38. Extra pair of Rx eyeglasses (per person)
  39. A pair of sunglasses for each person
  40. Box of large plastic trash bags

Evaluate

Resolve Problems by Brainstorming and Collaborating on Solutions

People have referred to brainstorming as rough-draft and out-of-the-box thinking. It brings to light ideas that are not yet fully formed. It also represents a shift in thinking from an “I-versus-you” to a “we-versus-the-problem” mind-set.

When you brainstorm, the immediate goal is to gather as many solutions to a problem as possible. Don’t censor yourself or each other. Be creative in your thinking. Build off each other’s ideas. Way-out ideas are welcome. Become like heated corn kernels just popping with ideas. The more ideas there are, the more options and wider the range of solutions there will be. There should be no negative evaluation or criticism of any suggestion at this stage. Only after you finish brainstorming should you evaluate which ideas make the most sense.

Illustration: Thinking Outside the Box

Silhouette of a camel caravan crossing the desert at sunset.

The story is told of a rich Bedouin sheik who owned several camels. He had three sons of 20, 18 and 12 years of age. Due to his advanced age, the sheik wrote his last will and testament. It read, in part, “I will that my oldest son shall inherit 1/2 of my camels as he will have to be responsible for all our clan. My middle son, who will serve as his brother’s assistant, shall receive 1/3 of my camels. My youngest son is still a child and the older sons will have to care for him; he shall get 1/9 of my camels.” Months later, the father died.

The sons had difficulty carrying out their father’s wishes. There were 17 camels at the time of his death. How would the brothers divide the camels? After discussing the matter at length, to no avail, they went to a judge for his counsel.

The judge suggested the sons sell all the camels and split the money. But the oldest son said, “I will respect the will of my father who did not want us to sell our inheritance.”

The judge said to the sons, “Why don’t you rent your camels to a merchant and share what he will pay? This way, you keep the property and have an income that you can share in the designated amounts.” But the middle son objected and said, “I am a merchant myself. I need my camels for my work.”

The judge grew impatient and declared, “The only solution, then, will be for you to slaughter the camels and eat or sell their meat.” But the youngest son wept. He said, “I have grown up with the camels. I love each one of them. They must not die.” The frustrated judge then said, “I cannot resolve your case.”

The sons went back to their tents. As they discussed their plight, the conversation became more agitated. Suddenly, over their raised voices, they heard a camel approaching.

A rider in traditional dress on a camel among red desert rocks.

Looking up, they recognized the rider as one of the wise men of the region, one to whom people would turn with their problems. The sons asked this man for his advice.

After they had told him about their dilemma, the wise man sat and thought. Eventually, he declared, “I will give my camel to your father’s estate. That will give you 18 camels. Following your father’s wishes, half shall go to the oldest son: 9 camels. One third shall go to the middle son: 6 camels. One ninth shall go to the youngest son: 2 camels. 9 plus 6 plus 2 makes 17 camels. That leaves one camel left over, which I would ask that you give back to me.”

The sons were happy to do so. In fact, they not only gratefully gave the wise man back his camel, but loaded it with gifts of appreciation.

Lesson

Sometimes solutions to problems seem insurmountable but are not. I have seen the practice of coming up with ideas (thinking creatively) work well for groups and for married couples. Try it for yourselves. You have nothing to lose except a problem.

The Groan Zone

A frustrated woman throwing papers into the air during a tense meeting.

There is a phenomenon known as the “Groan Zone,” a term coined by facilitator Sam Kaner.2 It describes the confusing and frustrating phase of discussion we often have to go through on the way to a solution. This concept is important to keep in mind when working on problems in your marriage.

To better understand the concept, watch this 2½-minute video.

▶  Watch: The Groan Zone

Although the presentation refers to groups at work, the concept applies to groups of two. In my practice, I have often observed that the best ideas and solutions emerge near the end of a difficult two-hour conversation, that is, after engaging in groan-zone-like conversation. Staying engaged with good intentions is key.

Levels of Agreement

Not every solution requires wild enthusiasm for its acceptance. As the scale below shows, there are different levels of support for an idea.3

These different levels of support reflect your ability to stay connected to your spouse even if you are not 100% behind an idea. They reflect your ability to collaborate with your spouse by making accommodations while not sacrificing your values. Sometimes love and the desire for peace supersede getting your own way. Being aware of these various levels of support, you may experience more “agreement” on an issue arising in the future compared to what you experienced in the past.

Discuss

Collaborate and Analyze a Recent Dispute to Prevent History from Repeating Itself

It is not unusual for couples to fall into the same cycle of conflict over and over. Over time, the groove of this repeating cycle deepens and becomes the primary, if not the only way, couples handle their disputes.

Bronze statue of a seated man resting his chin on his hand, deep in thought.

By taking the time to analyze a recent conversation that went “south,” you can be more conscious of how to alter the course of your future disputes. Let’s look at what happens during a typical argument. This should only take a moment or two.

Part One

Select a recent dispute the two of you had that didn’t end well. We want to make it a case study for this exercise. The goal of this exercise is not to rehash the argument, but to learn from it.

Part Two

Now begins the real work.

Review Chapter 6, “Does Your Communication Connect or Divide You?”

Compare this conversation with the positive aspects of communication that help couples stay connected, even during a heated conversation.

Analyze how you each communicated using the following checklist. To the extent you fell short, you want to focus on making improvements in those areas.

A row of empty checkboxes with a large red check mark in one of them.

Here are questions that can help in this endeavor.

Summary

It is hard for repeated patterns of behavior to change during conflict. It requires forethought.

What changes can you both decide on right now to change your negative cycle in the future? By working together and focusing on these areas before your next “conversation,” you may be amazed at how connected you remain.

A wooden footbridge crossing a rocky stream in a green forest.

1. Thomas, Kenneth W., and Ralph H. Kilmann, Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument (1974). The five styles in this chapter are adapted from their model. ↩

2. Kaner, Sam, et al., Facilitator’s Guide to Participatory Decision-Making (1996; 3rd ed. 2014). ↩

3. Adapted from the Gradients of Agreement scale developed by Sam Kaner, Duane Berger and the staff of Community At Work (1987), in Kaner, Facilitator’s Guide to Participatory Decision-Making. ↩

Struggling in your marriage?  There is hope.

Call Dr. Ken Newberger at 561-490-4991 to talk about your situation free of charge.  Or, if you prefer, learn about his unique process.